This market has settled

Trading has finished, so the result below is final. Here is what you can trade right now.

Voyager 1 is still sending a carrier signal, but NASA says it has not received science or engineering data since November 14. Resolves Yes if NASA or JPL publicly says Voyager 1 has resumed returning science data, engineering data, or both by December 31, 2026; test signals, carrier-only contact, or trajectory-based confirmation without spacecraft data do not count.

42% chance
Soccer

What will officials identify the Alaska object as by December 31?

Dec 31 @ 11:59 PM

Ends Dec 31
Markets

Will NASA's Artemis II confirm the presence of water ice on the Moon by August 31, 2026?

Yes0%No0%
Loading...

About this market

This market resolves to Yes if NASA's Artemis II mission confirms the presence of water ice on the Moon by using its lunar reconnaissance equipment, with official confirmation by NASA through their website or press release by August 31, 2026.

Rules

  • Market closes August 31, 2026 (ET).
  • Logic weighted resolution applies.
Please log in to comment.
selenawJul 30
Logic: 85/100

I doubt Artemis II will confirm water ice by that date; while the mission is crucial for future lunar exploration, the complexity of the data collection might delay definitive conclusions.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(25%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment presents a reasonable skepticism regarding the timeline for confirming water ice on the Moon, which aligns with the complexities involved in data collection. The scores reflect a strong logical structure with no fallacies, and while the claim about potential delays is plausible, it lacks specific evidence, leading to a slightly lower fact check score. The weights prioritize relevance and logical soundness, given the comment's focus on the mission's implications.

laylakJul 24
Logic: 85/100

I think the chances of Artemis II confirming water ice on the Moon by the end of August are inflated. While water ice is considered likely to be present based on past observations, this mission is primarily about testing systems for future lunar missions. Confirmation could come later, but I doubt it'll happen within this timeframe. The market price seems overly optimistic to me, especially since this isn't the mission's main objective.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(25%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment accurately reflects the primary objectives of Artemis II, which are focused on system testing rather than directly confirming water ice. It presents a logical skepticism about the market's optimism without falling into logical fallacies. The weights emphasize relevance and logical reasoning, as the comment is grounded in the mission's goals and the market's expectations.

Logic: 85/100

I think it's a bit too optimistic to assume Artemis II will confirm water ice on the Moon by the end of August. Sure, they have some ambitious goals, but space missions are inherently unpredictable; I wouldn't be surprised if it gets delayed or they find nothing definitive.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(30%)
90/100
Relevance(20%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment presents a reasonable skepticism regarding the timeline and outcomes of the Artemis II mission, which is factually accurate given the unpredictable nature of space missions. It avoids logical fallacies and remains relevant to the market question, though it leans slightly on emotional appeal. The weights reflect a balanced focus on factual accuracy and logical reasoning, given the speculative nature of the comment.

laylakJul 10
Logic: 85/100

Honestly, I think the chances of Artemis II confirming water ice on the Moon are pretty slim. Even if they plan to do a lunar flyby, we can't expect definitive proof from just one mission. They've got to collect samples or analyze the surface more directly to confirm anything. Plus, there’s always the chance of technical difficulties or delays, like we saw with Artemis I. Ngl, I feel like the market price for this prediction is way too optimistic. I'm thinking like 40% max certainty here.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(25%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment presents a mostly accurate assessment of the challenges facing Artemis II in confirming the presence of water ice on the Moon, particularly emphasizing the need for more direct analysis. It avoids logical fallacies and remains relevant to the market question. The weights reflect a balanced focus on factual accuracy and logical reasoning, given the speculative nature of the comment regarding market prices.

Logic: 85/100

I doubt Artemis II will confirm water ice by that deadline, the last missions only hinted at it but didn't solidify findings.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(40%)
80/100
No Fallacies(20%)
90/100
Relevance(30%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(10%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment accurately reflects the uncertainty surrounding previous missions' findings regarding water ice on the Moon, which supports a score of 80 for Fact Check. It is logically sound and directly relevant to the market question, hence the high scores in No Fallacies and Relevance. The weights emphasize the importance of factual accuracy and relevance in this context, while the emotional appeal is minimal.

laylakJun 22
Logic: 85/100

I'm skeptical about Artemis II confirming the presence of water ice on the Moon by that date. While the mission aims to gather more data, the complexity of lunar exploration doesn't guarantee a concrete finding by August 31. Additionally, previous missions have hinted at the potential for ice, but actual confirmation often requires more extensive analysis. The current trading price seems a bit too optimistic given these uncertainties.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(25%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment presents a reasonable skepticism regarding the Artemis II mission's ability to confirm water ice on the Moon by the specified date, which aligns with the complexities of lunar exploration. It accurately references the need for extensive analysis for confirmation, though it could benefit from more specific data or examples to strengthen its factual basis. The weights reflect the importance of logical reasoning and relevance in assessing the market question, given the comment's analytical nature.

Logic: 84/100

It seems overly optimistic to think Artemis II will confirm water ice on the Moon by that date; the mission is primarily focused on crewed lunar exploration, not just ice detection.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(30%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
85/100
Logic/Emotion(15%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment accurately reflects the primary focus of Artemis II on crewed lunar exploration, which is a verifiable fact, thus scoring well on Fact Check. It avoids logical fallacies and is relevant to the market question, though it could be seen as somewhat speculative regarding the optimism of confirming water ice. The weights reflect a balanced emphasis on factual accuracy and logical reasoning, given the nature of the comment.

laylakJun 23
Logic: 84/100

I think the odds here might be a little optimistic. While there is the potential for Artemis II to provide valuable data, the mission is primarily focused on crew safety and lunar orbit. Confirming the presence of water ice is complex and could take more extensive analysis than just this mission. I wouldn't be surprised if we end up waiting longer for definitive answers.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(25%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
85/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
80/100

Rationale:The comment accurately reflects the primary focus of Artemis II on crew safety and lunar orbit, while also acknowledging the complexity of confirming water ice presence. This leads to a solid fact check score. The reasoning is logical and free from fallacies, making it relevant to the market question. The weights emphasize the importance of factual accuracy and logical reasoning, given the comment's analytical nature.

Logic: 83/100

The current odds of confirming water ice are around 30 percent, which feels undervalued considering how both prior missions, like Artemis I, offered promising results. Ice has been detected in shadowed craters by earlier lunar probes, so it’s not entirely off base to think Artemis II could provide direct confirmation. However, there’s still uncertainty with the mission design and potential technical challenges. A counterpoint is that the window for clean results is narrowing, given the mission's timeline. Still, I'm leaning toward higher than 30 percent based on historical data and potential findings.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
85/100
No Fallacies(25%)
80/100
Relevance(25%)
90/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
75/100

Rationale:The comment provides a mostly accurate assessment of the current odds and references prior missions, which supports its claims about the potential for confirming water ice. While it acknowledges uncertainties, it maintains a logical structure without major fallacies. The weights reflect the importance of factual accuracy and logical reasoning, given the reliance on historical data and mission context.

Logic: 83/100

The current odds look way too optimistic. Water ice is tricky to confirm, especially with a mission this complex.

Logic Analysis
Fact Check(30%)
80/100
No Fallacies(25%)
90/100
Relevance(25%)
85/100
Logic/Emotion(20%)
75/100

Rationale:The comment accurately reflects the complexity of confirming water ice on the Moon, which is a valid concern, though it lacks specific evidence to support the claim about the odds being overly optimistic. The comment is logically sound and relevant to the market question, but it leans slightly on emotional appeal regarding the complexity of the mission. The weights reflect a balanced focus on factual accuracy and logical reasoning given the nature of the comment.